Don’t you JUST LOVE clichés? I spend an inordinate amount of time trying to avoid clichés, generally, in my life. But of course, dating is a minefield of them. “She was the one that got away” or “It’s not you, it’s meeee” or my personal favorite, “When you stop looking, that’s when he’ll show up!” The more sensitive among you will have to excuse me when I say “Oh… FUUUUCK YOU” to that one. This idea that, in order for the Universe to deliver your most Perfect Mate of Mates, you must absolutely stop caring about being alone gets more and more insanely offensive as you make your way through life as an aging single person. “Oh, it’s so easy!! I’m so happy and now do not care that I am alone in my bed each night and everyone I know is long-term attached and WHY SHOULD I CARE ABOUT ANY OF THAT HAHAHAHA LOLOL YOLO” and then pink glitter falls out of the sky and onto your Fancy-Free Single Gal Beret and you turn the corner and BAM! you and your rescued pit bull terrier and armful of flowers and dinosaur kale run right into the man of your dreams. A monkey could figure it out. Right?
I have pseudo-given up on love many times. After strings of meh dates or being really spectacularly dumped for the umpteenth time, who doesn’t? And I know that “stopping looking” and “giving up on love” are technically different, but frankly, the day when I have truly given up is the day I stop looking. I can’t have faith and not be looking. It doesn’t work like that for me. I’m always looking. I’m either looking to the guy who last broke my heart to realize he made a terrible mistake, or I’m looking at the gents in line at the cafe and forming romantic fantasies about them. What vexes me most about the “moment you stop looking…” cliché is that it implies that being “happily single” means you can’t also be looking for someone to build a life with.
With all those thoughts swimming through my mind (as always), I RSVPd “Yes” to a buddy’s (“Willis”) going-away party at a local bar. Looking BUT NOT LOOKING for love means you have to go to stuff because you never know who you’ll meet but you’re not really looking so it doesn’t matter if you meet anyone but you’ll never meet anyone you’re not looking for if you don’t go! Obviously.
A couple of months earlier, The Doctor had left me in a pile of Female Discards and I’d been trying to shake off my pissed. But I’d deleted his number earlier that day and felt confident as I headed out. The party was great: many cool chicks to get to know, and some males to boot. One of them (Bartender) started up a conversation with me as soon as I got there. He was a cute little sandy-haired guy with an easy-going demeanor and a serious appetite for books. He was intelligent, clearly into music, and had the same weird middle-of-the-week days off as me.
We were deep in talk when the bizarre staring incident with The Doctor occurred, but Bartender was not phased. It felt like he was creating this air of “Wow, that guy’s a dick and you should probably hang out with me instead” around him. As he hit the bar to fetch me a beer, Willis (drunk, but hey, it was his party) leaned over:
Willis: “You and Bartender.”
Me: “Oh, stoppppp*!”
(*don’t stop)
Willis: “Same days off. (*points at himself*) Matchmaker. Matchmaker. You and Bartender. Do it. He likes you.”
Me: ” …”
Willis: “Matchmaker.”
Willis doesn’t normally talk like a caveman, but he had better things to do* (*drink) and I couldn’t blame him for conserving his energy. Bartender and I exchanged numbers and I left on a little high. Though he was nearly 10 years younger than me (not ideal), I didn’t care. He was cute and smart and well-read. And it’s always great when you get that push you need to really move past someone.
Some days later I found out a band I dug was playing a show in town. Bartender was young and surely liked live musical rock concerts, so I decided it was the best idea ever to text and ask him to go. He agreed (with exclamation points!) and asked if I wanted to meet beforehand at one of my very, very favorite spots. I was stoked. It was going to be a perfect date.
When I got to Favorite Spot, he was already seated at the bar, deep in conversation with the bartender. (If you’ve ever dated or known a bartender, you understand that they all know each other and all think they are amazing and there is much vouching for their buddies.) I learned that Bartender’s favorite author was nearly next on my endless reading list, and that he liked to sit at Favorite Spot and just read, alone. My brain went, “I like that!! I like taking books to bars to read! We are going to embark on a dating relationship!”
At the show, he ran into even more friends who were all very slender and attractive. Bartender didn’t seem super into the music, but he looked like he was enjoying my company. Though, as he was talking to* (*yelling at; it was a rock show) his buddies, our age difference really started to hit me. These girls and boys were all far cooler than me (except the one in the gross short dreadlocks). And they were all hipsters (…except for the one in the gross short dreadlocks). And they all had perfect topknots and mustaches made from their shiny, youthful hair (EXCEPT FOR– I don’t even have to say it now). I chatted and danced with some of the girls, but I felt like a complete fraud the whole time. I felt like the older woman who was desperately trying to appear younger by putting on her 15 year-old daughter’s slutty clothes and inserting herself into a concert crowd and using phrases like, “OMG, toooootallyyyyy” and “Your tattoo of a Precious Moments figurine wearing a shirt with the American Apparel logo on it is soooooo awesommmmme.”
After the show, we bussed it back to our mutual neighborhood and ended up in front of my apartment. When I asked him if he wanted to come up for a drink, he said, “No, I should probably just head home. Tomorrow’s a long day.” Shot down. I was surprised. He’d paid me a fair amount of attention the night we met, and exclamation-pointed me when I proposed we go out. And Willis was obviously a matchmaker! Yeah, he was too young, but I knew couples with far larger age gaps.
A few days passed and I texted him about a book that had just come out by his favorite author, just to attempt a re-kickstarting of the conversation. Like so many others, I decided to patently disregard his very tremendous I AM JUST NOT THAT INTO YOU signal, hoping I could potentially remind him that A) I am very literary, just like you, Bartender!, B) The other night was fun! and now I have all these great new tattoo ideas, Bartender!, and C) I still exist as a human person, Bartender. He reciprocated, and we had a pretty decent back-and-forth. Did he ask me out again? No. Did that stop me from texting him about music the next day? No. (“OBVI.”)
As expected, he fell off the face of the earth. It annoyed me, but I figured it was probably for the best. I didn’t figure that to a degree that stopped me from going to his bar a couple more times, though (when I was fairly certain he’d be working), looking hot and acting like I didn’t care. In hopes, of course, that he would see D) The error of his ways and E) That I still existed as a human person. (*Cue the GD sad trombone.*) One of those nights, the friend I’d asked to meet me was running late, so I sat at his bar. We had a lovely little conversation that convinced me we should be dating. Later, not too intoxicated, really, I texted him what was probably THE MOST OBNOXIOUS message I have ever sent to a guy. It was the length of the entire screen and written in a steam-of-consciousness style one might call, “The Meth Bender.” But I was a bit tipsy and utterly convinced it was irreverent, funny, a smidge sexy, and basically perfect. Was there a response? Of course not.
I ended up in his bar a week or so later, and once again, sat down where he could serve me. I decided I was going to make one last communication effort, and that his response would tell me all I needed to know.
Me: Hi, Bartender. (*completely cool, normal-person smile*)
Bartender: Hey! How are you? (*does not acknowledge the text*)
Me: I’m awesome, thanks! (*does not acknowledge the not acknowledging of the text*) Things are super good. (*lying*) I’ll have an (overly pretentious artisanal drink). (*second completely cool, normal-person smile*)
(-a few minutes pass-)
Me: Hey, Bartender, so… sorry for that, um, pretty crazy text the other night. (*gauging his reaction; seeing he is not going to fall in love with me*)
Bartender: (*smiling*) What text?
Me: Ha ha ha. Yeah… I was preeeeetyyy drunk.
Bartender: I figured.
And… SCENE.
As ever, my dating life was teaching me a lesson. Or it was trying to. It was trying to teach me to respect the signals being given, and not pursue every dating avenue I’ve felt could have potential to the point of embarrassment. By the time Bartender and I had that non-discussion about the text, my self-worth as a dater was pretty damned low, and I knew I was forcing the issue far beyond the point I ever should have.
But that’s sometimes the trouble with looking for lasting love. (Yes I said “looking.” I’M LOOKING, UNIVERSE. GO AHEAD AND JUST SEND ME THE CERTIFIED LETTER TELLING ME I’LL DIE ALONE, SHIVERING IN MY FUR COAT AND CLENCHING A VIRGINIA SLIM BETWEEN MY GREY TEETH.) Sometimes when you’re looking, it’s easy to look right past your better judgement and try to manipulate situations into becoming what you want them to be, rather than just accepting them for the non-starters or poor fits or turds that will not be polished that they are. Lesson learned.
OMG, totes JKs!!! Totes JKs.
xx!